How to compare home warranty plans side by side
A fair comparison uses the same questions for every plan. Here is the list we use and how to fill it in without getting lost.
- HVAC
- Water heater
- Plumbing
- Electrical
- Kitchen appliances
- Laundry
- Roof
- Pool/spa
Comparing home warranty plans by their marketing pages is like comparing cars by their paint. You need to look under the hood. The good news is that every contract answers the same handful of questions. Ask them the same way for each plan and the comparison mostly does itself.
Start with your house, not the plans
Before you open a single contract, list what you actually own. Which systems does your home have? How old is each one? Do you have a pool, a well, a septic system, a second refrigerator? A plan that covers things you do not have is not a better plan for you.
Then mark the two or three items you would most hate to replace on short notice. Those are the rows you will read most carefully.
The seven rows that matter
Our worksheet uses seven rows. They cover almost everything that makes one plan different from another.
- Covered systems: which items are named, and which parts of each.
- Exclusions: what is left out, especially for your most important items.
- Service fee: the amount as written, and how it is charged.
- Coverage caps: per item, per system, and per term.
- Claim process: how to file, who picks the technician, how decisions are made.
- Cancellation terms: how to cancel, and what happens to fees already paid.
- Renewal terms: whether it renews on its own and whether terms can change.
Fill it in from the contract, not the brochure
Ask each company for a sample contract before you sign up. Fill in each row using the contract's own words. If you have to guess, write "not stated" and move on. A blank is useful information.
Keep the page numbers next to each answer. If you need to go back and check something, you will thank yourself.
Look for the gaps
Once all three columns are filled in, read across each row. Where do the plans differ? Often the biggest differences are in the caps for heating and cooling, the exclusions for older equipment, and the renewal terms.
Ask yourself which gaps you can live with. A lower cap on an item you rarely use may be fine. A broad exclusion on your oldest system may not be.
Questions worth asking each company
If something is unclear, send each company the same short list of questions. Their answers, and how clearly they give them, are part of the comparison.
- Can I use my own contractor, and what do I need to do first?
- How do you decide between repair and replacement?
- What records would you want to see to show an item was maintained?
- Can the terms change at renewal, and how would I be told?
Do not skip cancellation and renewal
It is easy to spend all your attention on coverage and forget the back of the contract. Cancellation and renewal terms tell you how easy it is to leave and what can change when the term ends. Look for the notice you have to give, whether any fees apply if you cancel early, and whether a plan renews on its own.
Also check how the company will tell you about changes at renewal. A short email the week before is very different from a written notice a month ahead. These rows rarely decide the comparison on their own, but they can break a tie, and they matter a lot if your needs change partway through the year.
Sign up directly, on your terms
We do not offer plans ourselves. Read the full contract of any plan you are considering before you sign up.
This guide is general information, not advice about any specific plan or contract. Always read your own contract.
